Scale problem

Jiwon

Hi. I received your comment.
I would like to seek your understanding that I can't speak English well.
I understand that scale problem is Spine bug and you can't fix that problem.
It wasn't fixed 1.9.09 too.
If it fixed to take a long time, I think you provide down grade Spine version is better.
1.9.05 has not problem.
Thank you.

Scale is applied according to each bone's local axis.

This makes root scaling only make sense if
(a) you scale both X and Y by the same amount or
(b) all child bones are facing the same direction as the parent

There was a recent bug where the image didn't follow the axis of its parent bone's scale. I'm not sure if that was fixed already.

Jiwon

Nate

This is not a bug, this is how scaling has always worked in Spine. More info on this type of scaling:
http://www.softimageblog.com/archives/84

If there is actually a bug with scaling, please explain what is the problem. I know English is not you first language. Maybe you can use pictures along with your text?

You can go back to any older version of Spine on the settings menu.

Pharan

I think that second part was copy-pasted from my comment from another thread.

In case anyone reading misunderstands that last part:
I meant, there was a recent bug where an image wasn't scaled (or rotated?) according to its bone's axis and got bent backwards and things.
But I believe that was fixed quickly and isn't a bug anymore. But that was the bug.

This per-bone-axis scaling behavior isn't a bug. It's part of how Spine was programmed.
The root bone wasn't designed to be scaled just on the X or Y axis.
And the axis of X and Y scaling weren't designed to be passed along to descendant bones.